A Definitive Guide to NAV in Mutual Fund: High vs. Low NAV Explained

NAV in mutual fund

Investing in mutual funds can often feel overwhelming, especially when it comes to understanding key concepts like NAV in mutual funds. NAV, or Net Asset Value, represents the per-unit value of a mutual fund and is a critical metric for evaluating a fund’s performance. However, many investors struggle with interpreting NAV, determining whether a low or higher NAV is better, or even understanding how it is calculated.

These challenges can make it difficult to choose the right mutual fund for your financial goals. By breaking down these complexities, this guide aims to provide clarity on how NAV works and why it matters. Whether you’re a new investor or looking to optimize your portfolio, understanding NAV can help you make more informed decisions, track the value of your investments, and align your strategy with your long-term objectives.

What is NAV in Mutual Funds?

Net Asset Value (NAV) is one of the most crucial metrics used in mutual fund literature. NAV represents the ‘worth’ of a mutual fund scheme and acts as a barometer for investors to evaluate capital appreciation. Similar to Earnings Per Share (EPS) for shareholders, NAV indicates the value of a mutual fund’s net portfolio divided by the total number of outstanding units.

NAV’s importance lies in its ability to reflect the performance of the fund. However, it does not measure whether a fund is undervalued or overvalued. It provides a snapshot of the fund’s per-unit value at a specific time, aiding investors in making informed decisions.

How is NAV Calculated in Mutual Funds?

To protect investors’ interests, SEBI mandates that all mutual funds declare NAV at regular intervals. However, SEBI doesn’t prescribe a fixed calculation method; instead, mutual fund companies must get their NAV formula approved. Broadly, there are two approaches to calculating NAV:

  1. Asset-Based Approach: Involves the market value or cost of investments, reduced by liabilities, and divided by the total number of outstanding units.
  2. Capital-Based Approach: Includes capital, reserves, appreciation of listed and unlisted securities, and net revenue, subtracting operational costs before dividing by the number of units.

NAV = (Value of Assets + Net Unrealized Gains – Liabilities) ÷ Outstanding Units

Role of Valuation in NAV

NAV calculations significantly depend on valuation methodologies and accounting policies. The valuation considers market rates, with options like highest, lowest, or mid-market rates at year-end. Adopting a conservative approach, such as using the lowest rate, is beneficial for open-ended funds as it maintains lower NAV levels, thereby minimizing cash outflows during repurchases.

Should NAV in Mutual Funds Be High or Low?

Many investors mistakenly believe that a low NAV fund is better because it seems cheaper or that a highest NAV fund is superior because it reflects success. However, the NAV importance lies in reflecting the per-unit value of a fund’s holdings and does not affect its ability to generate returns.

The reality is that the NAV value  of a fund  itself is irrelevant when assessing a mutual fund’s potential. A fund’s performance is driven by the stocks or securities it holds, not the NAV. The growth of a mutual fund depends on the performance of the stocks in its portfolio. A high NAV fund can outperform a low NAV fund if it holds strong-performing stocks, and vice versa

For example:

Nippon India Growth Fund  have a high NAV, but its returns are less compared to Nifty Midcap Index because the performance depends on the quality of its stocks.

Nippon growth fund NAV

Quant Midcap Fund, with a lower NAV, delivered superior returns because of its strategic investments in midcap stocks with strong growth potential.

Quant mid cap fund NAV

In both cases, the investment amount remains the same, and future growth depends on portfolio performance, not NAV levels.

Low or High NAV , Which is Good?

Another common misconception is that buying a fund with a lower NAV gives you more units, leading to better returns. However, the number of units you hold is irrelevant—your total returns depend on the percentage growth of the fund, not the number of units.

For instance:

  • If you invest ₹10,000 in a fund with an NAV of ₹10, you receive 1,000 units. If the NAV grows by 10%, your investment becomes ₹11,000.
  • Similarly, if you invest ₹10,000 in a fund with an NAV of ₹50, you receive 200 units. With the same 10% growth, your investment still becomes ₹11,000.

Impact of Market Valuations

NAV is determined based on year-end market rates. Valuation approaches can consider:

  1. Highest Rate: Captures the peak market value.
  2. Lowest Rate: Aligns with conservative principles, maintaining a lower NAV.
  3. Mid-Market Rate: A balanced approach.

Key Considerations for Choosing a Mutual Fund

When choosing a mutual fund, focusing on factors beyond NAV is crucial for making informed decisions. Start by examining the portfolio composition to ensure the fund’s holdings include stocks or securities in sectors with strong growth potential. A well-structured portfolio aligned with your risk tolerance and financial goals holds greater importance than the NAV itself.

Next, evaluate the historical performance of the fund. Consistency in outperforming its benchmark or peers over time is a reliable indicator of its potential for future returns. Additionally, consider the expense ratio, as a lower ratio ensures that a larger portion of your investment is allocated to growth rather than administrative costs.

The expertise of the fund manager also plays a critical role—look into their track record and strategy to assess their ability to generate strong returns. Lastly, assess how well the fund aligns with your financial objectives, whether that’s wealth creation, income generation, or long-term stability. Ensuring this alignment is far more significant than the NAV value, as it directly impacts your ability to meet your investment goals

 4. What are Advantages & Disadvantages of NAV

Net Asset Value (NAV) is a critical metric for investors in mutual funds ,It provides transparency, aids in decision-making, and helps track fund performance over time.

Advantages of Net Asset Value (NAV)

       1. Transparent Pricing

NAV ensures clear and transparent pricing for mutual fund units. It is calculated daily, reflecting changes in market conditions, corporate actions, and portfolio adjustments. This regular calculation provides investors with an accurate price for buying or selling fund units. For instance, if a mutual fund has assets worth ₹500 crore, liabilities of ₹50 crore, and 10 crore outstanding units, the NAV would be ₹45 per unit. This transparency eliminates ambiguity, making it easier for investors to understand the true value of their holdings.

  1. Performance Tracking

One of the key advantages of NAV is its ability to track a fund’s performance. The change in NAV over a specific period shows the fund’s rate of return, helping investors measure how well their investment is performing. For example, if the NAV of a fund increased from ₹40 to ₹50 over a year, this reflects a 25% growth in value. Such insights allow investors to assess whether the fund aligns with their financial goals.

  1. Entry and Exit Pricing

For open-ended mutual funds, NAV determines the price at which units are purchased or redeemed. This standard pricing mechanism ensures that all investors buy or sell units at a fair and consistent rate. For instance, if the NAV is ₹100 per unit, a ₹10,000 investment will fetch 100 units, regardless of when the transaction occurs during the day. This simplicity enhances the convenience and accessibility of mutual fund investments.

  1. Predicting Future Performance

Analyzing historical NAV trends helps investors gain insights into a fund’s potential future performance. While past performance doesn’t guarantee future results, trends in NAV can reveal patterns that guide investment decisions. For example, a fund with steadily increasing NAV over several years indicates strong portfolio management and reliable returns, giving investors confidence in its potential.

Disadvantages of Net Asset Value (NAV)

While Net Asset Value (NAV) is an essential metric for evaluating mutual funds, it has limitations that investors should understand.

  1. Delayed Calculations

NAV is calculated after market hours, making it less effective for real-time decision-making. During volatile market conditions, significant price gaps can occur, leaving investors unable to act on the latest price movements. For example, international funds may experience even greater delays due to time zone differences and foreign market closures, impacting the relevance of their NAV.

  1. Does Not Reflect Future Earnings

One of the key limitations of NAV is its inability to project future earnings. NAV solely represents the current market value of a fund’s assets and doesn’t account for their growth potential. For instance, a mutual fund holding undervalued stocks with strong future prospects will still reflect only their present market price, potentially underestimating the fund’s true worth.

  1. Impacted by Market Fluctuations

NAV is highly sensitive to market fluctuations, which can distort the perceived value of investments. For example, during a market downturn, the NAV might decline significantly, even if the underlying assets are fundamentally strong. This volatility can make it challenging for investors to accurately assess the long-term value of their investments.

  1. Ignores Asset Quality

While NAV incorporates the market value of assets, it doesn’t consider their quality. For example, two funds with identical NAVs could have vastly different portfolios—one comprising high-quality stocks and the other of lower-grade securities. Investors relying solely on NAV might miss these critical distinctions, leading to suboptimal investment choices.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

  1. What are NAV units in mutual funds?
    NAV units represent the number of mutual fund units you hold, calculated based on the NAV price when you buy or sell mutual fund units.
  2. Why does the NAV price vary across mutual funds?
    The NAV price reflects the current value of a fund’s portfolio, which varies depending on its assets, liabilities, and market performance.
  3. When does the NAV update for buy and sell transactions in mutual funds?
    The buy and sell NAV for mutual funds is updated daily at 8pm after the market closes, based on the day’s closing prices of the fund’s holdings. You can check the daily price changes here.
  4. How to compare two NAVs with direct NAV in mutual funds?
    Direct NAV in mutual funds excludes distributor commissions, often resulting in higher NAVs. Compare them based on fund performance, expense ratio, and portfolio composition rather than the NAV alone.
  5. Does a dividend get added to NAV?
    No, when dividends are distributed, the NAV is adjusted downward by the dividend amount. This ensures the fund’s value reflects the payout made to investors.

Conclusion:

Net Asset Value (NAV) stands for the per-unit value of a mutual fund and represents the net value of an asset after subtracting liabilities from the total asset value of the fund. It is calculated daily for open-end mutual funds, based on the closing price of the underlying assets. The importance of NAV lies in its role in helping investors track the fund’s value and make informed decisions. However, nav doesn’t necessarily indicate future growth, as the value of the fund’s assets and their performance matter more. Understanding the nav formula and its calculation empowers investors to evaluate mutual fund investments effectively.

 

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top